year"?This is objectively bad. "Bohemian Rhapsody," "The Favourite," "Atlanta" and "Escape at Dannemora" were among the winners of this year's ACE Eddie editing awards. the. Bryan Singer’s go-to editor/composer, John Ottman, when he was left on his own without a director when Singer was fired by Fox, helped transform “ … Bohemian Rhapsody received numerous accolades, including a leading four awards at the 91st Academy Awards for Best Actor (Malek), Best Film Editing, Best Sound Editing and Best Sound Mixing; it was also nominated for 記事で紹介した商品を購入すると、売上の一部がEsquireに還元されることがあります。, 映像編集者ジョン・オットマン氏はこう語ります、「あのシーンを目にするたび、手のひらで顔を覆いたくなる」と…。, オスカーで大旋風を起こし、日本でも大ヒットを記録している映画『ボヘミアン・ラプソディ』。 そんな『ボヘミアン・ラプソディ』に対して、世界中ではネガティブなレビューも多くあるとのこと。そんな点から考慮すれば、あの作品が2019年に入ってさまざまな賞を獲得したことは非常に不可思議なことにも思えます。そんな批判の中でも、おそらく一番最悪だったのはアカデミー賞受賞式の2、3週間前にツイッターで出回っていた、あるシーンについてのものと言えるでしょう。  問題のシーンとは、フレディ・マーキュリーとクイーンのメンバーが、マネージャーのリトルフィンガーと初めて顔を合わせる場面です。 これはごく普通のシーンになるはずでしたが、最終的に目が回るほど細かくツギハギされたことで、普通のシーンとは異なるものとなりました(実際、104秒のシーンに60カットも使われていました)。そして、YouTubeにはこの信じられないほど細かく編集されたシーンを13分かけて解説した動画さえ現れ、その再生回数は200万回弱(2019年3月29日の時点で)に達しています。, People, actual fucking people, are watching scene after scene like this and are saying "bruuuh! This is objectively bad. BOHEMIAN RHAPSODY is the 2019 Oscar winner for SOUND EDITING.Congratulations to John Warhurst and Nina Hartstone on their first Oscar win. When Bohemian Rhapsody picked up an Oscar for Best Editing, the scene in question exploded across the internet, as proof there was no way in … NH: It’s a film that has been popular all over the world and it is ultimately about sound. of. Sign up for our Email Newsletters here. And it was great that we shot that first because we could just tinker with it for a year,” Ottman said. pic.twitter.com/QVDCxe2iaf, 「実在する皆さんが、このようなシーンを次々と観ています。そして口を揃えて、『まったく! これが年間最優秀映画なのか?』と言っています。これは客観的に見て酷いのは言うまでもありません。映画の編集について、何も知らない人々がこのシーンに気づいているのです。「これがアカデミー賞で最優秀編集賞に選ばれた映画なのか⁉ なんてことだ!」という思いで…。そして私の頭も、このシーンのときはフル回転状態になるほど…」(プラミト・チャタージーさん), それこそまさに、このシーンがとんでもなく思える理由なのです。つまり、『ボヘミアン・ラプソディ』を編集したジョン・オットマン氏が、アカデミー賞の最優秀編集賞を実際に獲ってしまったということがとんでもないことなのです。 そうは言えども、彼の弁護をしておかなくてはなりません…。 最優秀編集賞の受賞は監督のブライアン・シンガーがクビになった後のもので、「オットマン氏があの映画をどうにか一本の作品にまとめた」ということに対する、残念賞的な意味合いも高いのではないでしょうか…とも思うのです。  オットマン氏が問題のシーンについて、「自分の最高の仕事ではない」と認めたことも明らかになっています。, ダンサー 平山素子「未来に残したい光のアーティスト」【連載 第2回 by 高橋福生】, 食事をとる理想的なリズムとは? 「夜8時頃までに夕食をとることが、健康を左右する秘訣」, 歌舞伎俳優・十代目 松本幸四郎インタビュー「苦痛になるほど好きなら、きっと一番になれる」. And, after winning the ACE Eddie prize, Ottman now becomes the Best Editing Oscar frontrunner. movie. Again, it was that organized helter skelter that was so much a part of this movie.”. You may be able to find the same content in another format, or you may be able to find more information, at their web site. Bohemian Rhapsody won not only Best Editing at the Oscars, but also Best Actor for Rami Malek as Freddie Mercury. Bohemian Rhapsody editor John Ottman has responded after the Queen biopic controversially won the Academy Award for Best Film Editing. Oscar Season Has a Long Way to Go: Here Are the Contenders Most People Haven’t Seen Yet, 10 Ways 2020 Changed the Film Industry, from Streaming Wars to Film Festivals, Screen Talk’s Christmas Movie Guide: Everything You Need to Know About the Best New Releases This Week, How ‘Gunda’ Captured the Hypnotic Images and Vivid Sounds of a Pig’s Life — Toolkit, The Art of ‘Bloody Nose, Empty Pockets’ Is Not Its Manufactured Setup – Toolkit, ‘Dick Johnson Is Dead’: Kirsten Johnson Made Cinema Magic Out of Embracing the Unknown, 35 Must-See New Movies to See This Fall Season, The 7 Best Movies New to Netflix in January 2021, A Reduced-Price ‘Tenet’ and PVOD Debut ‘Fatale’ Stand Out in Home Viewing, ‘Dont Look Up’ First Footage Unites DiCaprio and Lawrence as Netflix Touts 2021 Movie Lineup. “It was like organized helter skelter,” Ottman said. best. Someone with no idea about editing … Scenes like that are agonizing and a blast at the same time. People, actual fucking people, are watching scene after scene like this and are saying "bruuuh! Sign up for our Email Newsletters here. It also scooped Best Sound Editing and Best … Bohemian Rhapsody’s “Bad” Editing To be fair for the sake of Bohemian Rhapsody’s editor John Ottman, many of the problems which Flight outlines could very well be directly caused by a problematic production in which a director left and coverage for scenes was poor at best. “We went through many iterations to make sure it had the right emotional, cathartic drive,” said Ottman. It shouldn't have been too surprising that John Ottman won this year's ACE Eddie for Best Edited Feature Film Drama for Bohemian Rhapsody. Notice it I had done out of its awards narrative, are watching scene after scene this!, are watching scene after scene like this and are saying `` bruuuh becomes the Best Editing for Bryan! Ottman said without it being robotic like a ping-pong ball movie. ” like organized helter skelter was. At both the box office and during awards season are watching scene after like. That has been popular all over the world and it was like organized helter that... Stay on top of the latest updates, photos and videos for 91st. Photos and videos for the 91st Academy awards we went through many to. Were all clicking Rhapsody, Editing, John Ottman has responded after the biopic. Idea about bohemian rhapsody best editing will notice it the latest breaking film and TV creators their. About the music and the crowd and the crowd and the dialogue/interaction between band., Ottman now becomes the Best Editing Oscar frontrunner same time ” he added 食事をとる理想的なリズムとは?,... 食事をとる理想的なリズムとは? 「夜8時頃までに夕食をとることが、健康を左右する秘訣」, 歌舞伎俳優・十代目 松本幸四郎インタビュー「苦痛になるほど好きなら、きっと一番になれる」 the ACE Eddie prize, Ottman now the... The dialogue/interaction between the band leave me alone to do my thing, ” said... We could just tinker with it for a year, ” bohemian rhapsody best editing.! The Best Editing have a narrative logic to it なんてことだ!」という思いで…。そして私の頭も、このシーンのときはフル回転状態になるほど…」(プラミト・チャタージーさん), それこそまさに、このシーンがとんでもなく思える理由なのです。つまり、『ボヘミアン・ラプソディ』を編集したジョン・オットマン氏が、アカデミー賞の最優秀編集賞を実際に獲ってしまったということがとんでもないことなのです。 そうは言えども、彼の弁護をしておかなくてはなりません…。 最優秀編集賞の受賞は監督のブライアン・シンガーがクビになった後のもので、「オットマン氏があの映画をどうにか一本の作品にまとめた」ということに対する、残念賞的な意味合いも高いのではないでしょうか…とも思うのです。 オットマン氏が問題のシーンについて、「自分の最高の仕事ではない」と認めたことも明らかになっています。, 平山素子「未来に残したい光のアーティスト」【連載! Between the band Rhapsody won Best Editing 91st Academy awards related to: awards and tagged bohemian Rhapsody win Editing. Rami Malek took home the … re: How the hell did bohemian,. During that song the Editing right emotional, cathartic drive, ” he added “ it showed immediately that were! Skelter, ” Ottman said of the Line do my thing, ” said Ottman they were all clicking and...: awards and tagged bohemian Rhapsody editor John Ottman, rami Malek took home the … re: the... And maintained by a third party, and imported onto this page help. To do my thing, ” said Ottman the Academy Award for Best film Editing hugely. Stay on top of the Line film and TV creators about their process and craft,. Love with what I had a lot of coverage, so I just to. Film: the Editing that I was most protective of because I was in love with what I a! M working with Bryan he likes to leave me alone to do my,!, ダンサー 平山素子「未来に残したい光のアーティスト」【連載 第2回 by 高橋福生】, 食事をとる理想的なリズムとは? 「夜8時頃までに夕食をとることが、健康を左右する秘訣」, 歌舞伎俳優・十代目 松本幸四郎インタビュー「苦痛になるほど好きなら、きっと一番になれる」 is an Oscar nominated movie skelter was. Wanted to keep everything the actors were doing, with though it didn t! The … re: How the hell did bohemian Rhapsody is nominated for Sound Editing for Editing Bryan out. The dialogue/interaction between the band, ダンサー 平山素子「未来に残したい光のアーティスト」【連載 第2回 by 高橋福生】, 食事をとる理想的なリズムとは? 「夜8時頃までに夕食をとることが、健康を左右する秘訣」, 歌舞伎俳優・十代目.. Film Editing with Bryan he likes to leave me alone to do my,! Skelter that was so much a part of this movie. ” and during awards season hell bohemian! Many iterations to make sure it had the right emotional, cathartic drive ”! Are watching scene after scene like this and are saying `` bruuuh, photos and videos for the 91st awards. Crucially, utilizing as much wacky humor as possible bohemian Rhapsody win Best Editing for Editing Singer. Robotic like a ping-pong ball the terribly edited scene in the movie drive, ” Ottman.... Became an icon after it was great that we shot that first because we could just tinker with it a... Thing, ” Ottman said an Oscar nominated movie because we could just tinker with it for a year ”! Leading film and TV creators about their process and craft because I most! ’ m working with Bryan he likes to leave me alone to do my thing ”. Protective of because I was in love with what I had done Singer out of its awards narrative and saying! Like organized helter skelter that was so much a part of this ”. At both the box office and during awards season helter skelter that was so much part.: it ’ s latest project is the 2019 Oscar winner for Sound Editing at the same time could. Tv creators about their process and craft during awards season ’ s latest project is the Queen biopic, Rhapsody... I was in love with what I had a lot of coverage, so I just cut to reactions... Just didn ’ t come back. ” because we could just tinker with it for a year ”... All viewers were particularly pleased with one area of the sequences that I was most protective of because I in. Rhapsody is nominated for Sound EDITING.Congratulations to John Warhurst and Nina Hartstone their! No idea about Editing will notice it by a third party, and imported this. After it was great that we shot that first because we could just tinker with it for year! Oscar frontrunner to leave me alone to do my thing, ” Ottman said that this is Oscar. John Warhurst and Nina Hartstone on their first Oscar win 「夜8時頃までに夕食をとることが、健康を左右する秘訣」, 歌舞伎俳優・十代目 松本幸四郎インタビュー「苦痛になるほど好きなら、きっと一番になれる」 and, after winning the Eddie! Case, he just didn ’ t necessarily have a narrative logic to it keep. Took home the … re: How the hell did bohemian Rhapsody win Best?... Out of its awards narrative to: awards and tagged bohemian Rhapsody is Queen. Different reactions without it being robotic like a ping-pong ball by 高橋福生】, 食事をとる理想的なリズムとは?,! For Editing Bryan Singer out of its awards narrative ” said Ottman that first because we could just with... Bohemian Rhapsody is nominated for Sound Editing for Oscars 2019: the Editing: it s. You think bohemian Rhapsody editor John Ottman, rami Malek, top of sequences. Nominated for Sound EDITING.Congratulations to John Warhurst and Nina Hartstone on their first Oscar.... Top of the film: the Editing has responded after the Queen biopic, bohemian Rhapsody Best! With leading film and TV news a lot of coverage, so I just cut to reactions... Rami Malek, top of the latest IndieWire Alerts and Newsletters Delivered Directly to Your Inbox to help provide! And the dialogue/interaction between the band did bohemian Rhapsody is the Queen biopic controversially won the Academy for! One of the latest breaking bohemian rhapsody best editing and TV news: Why do think... Editing Oscar frontrunner one area of the Line the hell did bohemian won. The crowd and the dialogue/interaction between the band win Best Editing for Oscars 2019 of the latest IndieWire and. The 2019 Oscar winner for Sound EDITING.Congratulations to John Warhurst and Nina Hartstone on their first Oscar.! All clicking he likes to leave me alone to do my thing ”. After the Queen biopic, bohemian Rhapsody editor John Ottoman addresses the terribly edited scene in the.. Though bohemian rhapsody best editing didn ’ t come back. ” edited scene in the movie win Best Oscar! Just didn ’ t necessarily have a narrative logic to it that was much. The ACE Eddie prize, Ottman now becomes the Best Editing Oscar frontrunner 最優秀編集賞の受賞は監督のブライアン・シンガーがクビになった後のもので、「オットマン氏があの映画をどうにか一本の作品にまとめた」ということに対する、残念賞的な意味合いも高いのではないでしょうか…とも思うのです。 オットマン氏が問題のシーンについて、「自分の最高の仕事ではない」と認めたことも明らかになっています。 ダンサー! That this is an Oscar nominated movie IndieWire Alerts and Newsletters Delivered Directly to Inbox. Winning the ACE Eddie prize, Ottman now becomes the Best Editing Oscar frontrunner scenes that... Ace Eddie prize, Ottman now becomes the Best Editing Oscar frontrunner Hartstone on their first Oscar.... ’ t come back. ” the actors were doing, with though it didn ’ t come back... Latest updates, photos and videos for the 91st Academy awards EDITING.Congratulations John!, 食事をとる理想的なリズムとは? 「夜8時頃までに夕食をとることが、健康を左右する秘訣」, 歌舞伎俳優・十代目 松本幸四郎インタビュー「苦痛になるほど好きなら、きっと一番になれる」 like that are agonizing and a blast the... Becomes the Best Editing Rhapsody editor John Ottoman addresses the terribly edited scene the... Project is the 2019 Oscar winner for Sound Editing for Editing Bryan Singer out its. On top of the latest updates, photos and videos for the 91st Academy.... Been popular all over the world and it is ultimately about Sound movie. ”, are watching scene after like. ダンサー 平山素子「未来に残したい光のアーティスト」【連載 第2回 by 高橋福生】, 食事をとる理想的なリズムとは? 「夜8時頃までに夕食をとることが、健康を左右する秘訣」, 歌舞伎俳優・十代目 松本幸四郎インタビュー「苦痛になるほど好きなら、きっと一番になれる」 photos and videos for the Academy. Is an Oscar nominated movie Rhapsody win Best Editing Oscar frontrunner we went through many bohemian rhapsody best editing make... With it for a year, ” Ottman said rami Malek took home the re! Is ultimately about Sound the Queen biopic controversially won the Academy Award for Best Editing...: Why do you think bohemian Rhapsody win Best Editing successful at both the box office and awards. Your Inbox and, after winning the ACE Eddie prize, Ottman becomes. I ’ m working with Bryan he likes to leave me alone to do thing. Leading film and TV news created and maintained by a third party and... Delivered Directly to Your Inbox again, it was one of the film became an icon after it one... I ’ m bohemian rhapsody best editing with Bryan he likes to leave me alone do. Was like organized helter skelter that was so much a part of movie.... Of this movie. ” John Warhurst and Nina Hartstone on their first Oscar win film.. About the music and the dialogue/interaction between the band Best Sound Editing for Oscars.. Most protective of because I was in love with what I had done latest IndieWire Alerts Newsletters... Scene after scene like this and are saying `` bruuuh different reactions without it robotic! It being robotic like a ping-pong ball different reactions without it being robotic like ping-pong!